In its report, Defence in the High North, published on 22 October 2026, the committee called for under-ice operations to be restored on at least some Astute-class attack submarines as quickly as possible. It asked the government to explain what progress it had made when responding to the report.
The Ministry of Defence has been certifying Astute-class boats to take over the role previously carried out by Trafalgar-class submarines, according to ministerial statements cited by MPs. The last Trafalgar-class boat retired in 2025, leaving a gap that the committee said had become more serious as the region’s strategic importance grew.
“The UK has allowed its under-ice submarine capability to lapse at a time when the High North has become strategically more important,” the report said. MPs warned that the shortfall risked forcing Britain into a more defensive position.
Russia could keep its ballistic missile submarines protected beneath the ice while sending attack submarines forward to threaten British infrastructure, NATO shipping and allied nuclear deterrents, the committee said. An ability to challenge those protected areas would put greater pressure on Russia to defend its own submarines.
The report drew on Royal United Services Institute analysis which concluded that shortages of submarines and under-ice proficiency had made NATO’s forward maritime strategy of the 1980s unrealistic to repeat. That strategy sought to threaten Soviet ballistic missile submarines in their northern bastion and hunt submarines attempting to enter the Atlantic to attack reinforcements and supplies heading for Europe.
Restoring under-ice operations will require specialist equipment and crews familiar with the conditions beneath the ice pack. The report highlighted the need for modifications such as a hardened sail structure for breaking through ice when surfacing, alongside knowledge of the region’s distinctive acoustic conditions.
The most recent Arctic Ice Exercise involving a Royal Navy submarine took place in 2018, according to ministerial statements cited in the report. Dr Marc De Vore, a senior lecturer at the University of St Andrews, told the inquiry that British submarines had not operated beneath the ice pack between the late 1990s and 2018, and that much of the expertise lost during that period would take time to rebuild.
The committee’s recommendation covered both restoring the equipment capability and maintaining proficiency once boats were cleared to operate beneath the ice. MPs called for regular exercises so that Astute-class submarines could sustain effective operations in the High North.




